Which to Choose - a Small or Large Aquarium

Most aquarists are dictated to by circumstance.world more within the reach of the aquarist with a
There is a really big aquarium, at a really good price,restricted financial ability.
but one rather definite problem, and that is there'sThere are aquarists who run a larger reef aquarium
nowhere to put it. So a smaller aquarium is chosen,and also run a fish only one as well. This is probably
but not by choice. However, even in the describedthe best of both worlds. Then there are the
circumstances, a smaller aquarium could be the oneaquarists, usually advanced, who run a larger aquarium
of choice.of whatever type and also run a nano aquarium,
Most aquarists dream big, visualizing that finalsometimes two, so that particular aspects of marine
aquarium that will bring the ultimate reef. In mostlife can be studied.
cases, it never materializes. Some are lucky ofSo what are the advantages of a nano aquarium?
course. There are some beautiful big reefs about.The term nano is applied to an aquarium up to 50
There are also some beautiful small reefs about, butgallons. The nano can start at a size of 10 gallons or
the beauty is not 'in the face'. It is in the detail.slightly less. So it becomes pretty obvious that the
There is one aquarium type where, I would imagine,set up costs are minimized. In the fish only nano,
bigger is usually best. That is the fish only aquarium.there is the cost of the fish, of course, and the
When an aquarium system is considered, betweenseawater mix, and any sand base that might be
reef and fish only, if say angels and butterfly fish areused, and the heating/lighting. Plus any ordinary rock
to be kept, then fish only is the choice. Some angelwhich is required. If 'live' rock and one or two small
and butterfly fish are said to be reef friendly, butcorals are incorporated then the cost will rise but not
many are not. The aquarist with a big fish onlysignificantly. So the demand on the wallet is not going
aquarium will have a lot of choice of fish, with all theto be high. Running costs are low. Water changes will
colour and interest that goes with them. If thenot amount to many gallons and are effective, if
aquarium was smaller, then fish loading would have todone weekly, to maintain water quality. If there is a
be reduced. This does not mean to say that a fishcalcium etc requirement then commercial additives
only small aquarium is a waste of time, it is not. Inshould last a long time. There should be no
this case, though, the choice of fish is limited, in sizerequirement for expensive add-on equipment. If
and territoriality. For example, it would be wrong todesired nano aquariums can be purchased ready for
house a surgeon fish in a nano aquarium.use at reasonable prices in designs that fit into the
Small aquariums such as the nano should house fishmodern house well. There are potential problems
of appropriate size. Perhaps the common clownfishthough. If the aquarist overstocks then water quality
(Amphiprion oscellaris) would be suitable, or otheris going to suffer. The small seawater gallonage is
small fish such as the Neon goby (Elacatinussubject to negative change, maybe caused by the
oceanops) and similar. In the larger nano aquarium,aquarist (overfeeding, overdosing), or caused by
fish such as dwarf angels (Centropyge sp) could beexternal influences (overheating). So the nano
suitable. Stocking levels have to be a disciplined affairaquarist has to be extra vigilant on water
with the very small nano aquariums, and notparameters.
excessive with the larger ones. The fish onlyWhat of aquariums that are over 50 gallons in
aquarium of whatever size has the advantage that,capacity? The bigger they get, the more money is
although water quality is important, there is no greatgoing to be needed. The cost of a fairly large
need to worry about calcium and the like, the needaquarium, when furnished with 'live' rock, sand bed,
being to keep nitrates and phosphates as low asprotein skimmer, corals and fish can run into
possible. So if the desire is to have a good number ofthousands. Not cheap. Likewise the fish only system.
exotic fish which may not be reef friendly, a largerThe large amount of seawater required, any 'live'
aquarium will do. If the idea is to have one or tworock used, a protein skimmer, sand bed etc plus all
small fish then a nano will be fine. Both types willthe fish again is a significant cost. Larger aquariums
need suitable decoration for the fish to feel secure.can also be purchased ready for use. The cost of
If the aquarist yearns for a reef tank, and wants tothese is very high. Against that, the larger aquariums
emulate as close as possible the corals of the reef inare more naturally stable. The aquarist needs to
quantity then a larger aquarium is going to bemake a major blunder to badly overdose the
required. The fish stocks have to be controlled asaquarium. Feeding likewise, though the larger numbers
reef unfriendly fish are not required, and too manyof fish in a fish only aquarium plus overfeeding could
fish will tend to depress the water quality despitespell trouble. External influences can cause problems
modern equipment. The aquascaping of the reef iswith overheating, the larger aquarium does not
fun, and the aquarist will, with care and attention,escape this. Halide lighting and warmer weather will
achieve a beautiful reef. The reef will never properlycause a temperature rise. However, the temperature
emulate nature's own, of course. There is a lack ofrise will occur more slowly because of the higher
size, a lack of diversity, and reef unfriendly fish arevolume of water. Generally, as the aquarium is larger
missing.it is usually easier, more practical, and financially more
Then there is the aquarist who is very interested inacceptable to take action to control temperature rise
detail. They do not want a big reef, but a very smallwith fans or, if really necessary, a cooler (chiller). By
section of a reef so the detail of the development ofthis it is meant that fixing cooling apparatus to a
the life on a rock or two can be watched inlarger aquarium is easier than doing so with a very
particular. Or perhaps the antics of two small fish aresmall nano aquarium, and the high cost of a seawater
the attraction. Here the nano will be suitable, as a 'live'cooler is more acceptable on a very expensive
rock or two of suitable size will be all that is required.aquarium. It can be done with a nano, of course, and
Then the aquarist can stock a coral or two, plusfor the sake of the life in the aquarium stable
perhaps a suitable shrimp, or go for a fish or two. Itparameters are needed.
is most probable that the aquarists who deliberatelySo, it's 'horses for courses' as they say. We each
choose a nano tank when there is room forhave our own ideas and we know our financial
something larger are few.capabilities. Whatever the choice, marine life is
Again as said, most aquarist's vision is of the big one.fascinating.
The nano aquarium also brings the fascinating marine